What I DON'T Want To Tell My Friend

The topic about this isn't too serious, but hey, we can post whatever, right?

So, my friend started writing stories. And I hate them. I don't hate them with a burning passion, but I hate them in a way that they suck. Really suck. He started writing them once he got this idea for some lamely annoying series that he though of, and he started writing ugly stories ever since. It was a very lazy attempt that I've talked to all of my friends with the exception of him.

He's a good friend, he's nice. But his stories suck. Yet for some reason, he doesn't seem to acknowledge their lack of quality at all. Here's an example of what he wrote.

[p= ]The four elements; the water, air, fire, and earth. Years ago, they are all against each other. they are arguing about who is the most powerful of them all. They usually fight each other, but in different chances. Water always fights Fire, while Air and Earth usually attack each other. One day, they meet each other in the space. they are very angry at each other so after exchanging bad looks to one another, they started to run towards their opponents to kill them. They all move in full speed then, the clash happened. It resulted in to a bright explosion. The explosion caused for the elements to combine and as a result, the world, Earth, was created. In the elements anger, many creature lived up to now...[/p]

Several things:
1. Ugly phrasing.
2. Engrishy
3. Derivative
4. Lame use of punctuation
5. Stale
6. "Many creature lived up to now", WTF does that mean?

Just several things. I would say these to him, but he doesn't seem to understand the concept of constructive criticism. For example. I said that his essay was a little generic, he didn't talk to me for the rest of the day. He treats all criticism as insults. He takes them as directly pointed to him, instead of his work, and he never takes it.

Here's more:

Once there was a boy. He is already an orphan, his parents died when he was one year old due to the war that occurred in their place. The war caused a lot of damages. Many lives were ended and many building were destroyed. The boy is now all alone by himself. He lives in a small house. He sells rags so that he can somehow earn money for his own survival.

Every night, he stares out his window and looks to the sky. He close his eyes and whispered, "I wish I will see my parents even just in my dreams," as he say these words, tears started to fall from his closed eyes.

Without the knowledge of the boy, a wishing star heard him. The star stares at the boy and starts thinking. The star knows the wishing stars' rule. The is that they can freely make human wishes come true, but in one condition and it is the star will die. When wishing stars die, they became shooting stars that grants wishes. When the star die, the wish that it chooses to be fulfilled will surely be fulfilled.

The star thinks of what he will do. Then the star's mother called it, "Hey! Dalut, where are you? It is time to sleep, I told you! You stubborn star!"

Dalut is the name of the wishing star. He is known as a mean star. He always bully other stars, especially the young once. Dalut looked back to the boy. Dalut can hear his wishes, then Dalut laughed at him and said, "What a poor boy. Let's see if your wish will come true," then he laughed again.

It was already time for Dalut to sleep but he can't. the boy was still staring at the stars that time. the boy was still crying. Dalut watches every movement of the boy. It is also time for the boy to sleep and so the boy fixes the floor where he will sleep. Before he closed his eyes, he looked at the starts again. He was amazed to what he was. He saw a shooting star. He looks at it as it fell until it is already out of sight. The boy was already sleepy so he went to sleep.

"Marcus?" the boy heard his name in his dream. "Marcus?" the boy turned around and he saw his mother. He runs as fast as he could approaching ti his mother. "I hope this is not just a dream, mother." the boy said. "I also hoped, but someone is waiting for you." replied his mother. "Who?" the boy asked. His mother replied, "Your father. He is still alive. Now go and look for him!"

In his mother's last word, the boy-Marcus- waked. The sun is now shining. He thought of what his mother said. He run and looked for his father in a hurry, but as he opened the door of his room, he saw a man waiting at the kitchen. The boy looks at the man's face as he walks near him. As Marcus recognizes the face, tears run down this cheeks. Marcus shouted, "FATHER!"

...Meanwhile...

"Dulat? Dulat! Where are you?" shouted the mother of Dulat. She waited but there is no response. She approach Dulat and to her surprise, Dulat is no where. the mother of Dulat cried then a senior star came near her and said, "I congratulate you, Semerya. Dulat has made a good job last night." "What are you saying, master Lopi?" she asked. The senior star answered, "Dulat made his job as a wishing star last night. He made a little boy very happy. I am very proud of your son." Semerya cried and whispered, "I am very proud of you Dulat. I am very proud of you."

I can point out a lot of things here. I'm too tired to though.

Comments

You gotta start from somewhere, most of the time peoples first stories always suck.
 
[quote name='KingdomBlade' post='3562274' date='Apr 1 2011, 02:40 PM']Just several things. I would say these to him, but he doesn't seem to understand the concept of constructive criticism. For example. I said that his essay was a little generic, he didn't talk to me for the rest of the day. He treats all criticism as insults. He takes them as directly pointed to him, instead of his work, and he never takes it.[/quote]

The problem with people like this is that you'll never be able to convince them of anything (contrary to their opinion). They all have an inflated sense of self worth and the first thing that'll pop into their head is "they're just jealous".
 
[quote name='Duskye' post='3562278' date='Apr 1 2011, 10:43 PM']You gotta start from somewhere, most of the time peoples first stories always suck.[/quote]

This is not his first story. It's the most recent in a long chain of sucky ones. He's written more of these... things.

[quote name='Law' post='3562283' date='Apr 1 2011, 10:44 PM'][quote name='KingdomBlade' post='3562274' date='Apr 1 2011, 02:40 PM']Just several things. I would say these to him, but he doesn't seem to understand the concept of constructive criticism. For example. I said that his essay was a little generic, he didn't talk to me for the rest of the day. He treats all criticism as insults. He takes them as directly pointed to him, instead of his work, and he never takes it.[/quote]

The problem with people like this is that you'll never be able to convince them of anything (contrary to their opinion). They all have an inflated sense of self worth and the first thing that'll pop into their head is "they're just jealous".
[/quote]

It's not that, he doesn't have that at all. It's just that his brain tends to misinterpret and mix-up the two things. He doesn't seem to understand. I'm not sure what he thinks of his own stories though, I think he takes a neutral stance, but no one has told him how bad it is.
 
Just let his stories keep sucking. If he can't take constructive criticism he's never going to improve.
 
[quote name='Narayan' post='3562294' date='Apr 1 2011, 10:50 PM']is he a close friend?[/quote]
Very, very close.
 
His stories really do suck...

Maybe you should convince him to post them online on some forum or something and when he gets shit he'll either fall into an abyss of despair and never write another story again or he'll try to improve himself and take constructive criticism.
 
[quote name='Domination' post='3562304' date='Apr 1 2011, 04:54 PM']His stories really do suck...

Maybe you should convince him to post them online on some forum or something and when he gets shit he'll either fall into an abyss of despair and never write another story again or he'll try to improve himself and take constructive criticism.[/quote]
I'd suggest FictionPress.
 
[quote name='Domination' post='3562304' date='Apr 1 2011, 02:54 PM']His stories really do suck...

Maybe you should convince him to post them online on some forum or something and when he gets shit he'll either fall into an abyss of despair and never write another story again or he'll try to improve himself and take constructive criticism.[/quote]

He'll start writing fanfiction and somehow get praise.
 
[quote name='Domination' post='3562304' date='Apr 1 2011, 10:54 PM']His stories really do suck...

Maybe you should convince him to post them online on some forum or something and when he gets shit he'll either fall into an abyss of despair and never write another story again or he'll try to improve himself and take constructive criticism.[/quote]

That's a good idea. Perhaps I could do that. :) I'm meeting with him tomorrow actually so perhaps perfect timing.

[quote name='Narayan' post='3562309' date='Apr 1 2011, 10:56 PM']he should read lots of books. and let him compare.[/quote]

He's read plenty, and some that I even like personally. Paul Coelho (his favorite book of all time is The Alchemist) is one. He also like Stephen King's Dark Tower series.
 
i still haven't never read those books. but he,on the other hand, have read better books and yet he still sucks.
 
[quote name='Narayan' post='3562336' date='Apr 1 2011, 11:04 PM']i still haven't never read those books. but he,on the other hand, have read better books and yet he still sucks.[/quote]

I know.

He also doesn't seem to get the huge gap in quality between my stories and his stories. If I say my stories are better, he will say "you're boasting". Even though it is in fact true.

In case you're wondering, here's my collection: http://gbatemp.net/t283965-short-story
 
[quote name='mezut360' post='3564126' date='Apr 2 2011, 02:38 AM']did you actually type this up!!?[/quote]
I'm afraid I'm not sure what you're asking. His friend wrote some shitty stories and his friend is mistaken in thinking that they are good. If you're asking if Blade did it, then no.
 
[quote name='mezut360' post='3564126' date='Apr 2 2011, 04:38 PM']did you actually type this up!!?[/quote]

Erm, what? These are my friend's stories. I reposted them from his blog (which I won't link here since he might track it back :P )
 
Has he ever watched "Avatar: The Last Airbender" before. The opening scene sounds quite similar to the opening in his story. XD
 
[quote name='Wabsta' post='3564413' date='Apr 2 2011, 08:57 PM']I liked the part where they suddenly met in space.[/quote]

I LOL'd at the sarcastic comment. XD
 

Blog entry information

Author
KingdomBlade
Views
250
Comments
46
Last update

More entries in Personal Blogs

More entries from KingdomBlade

Share this entry

General chit-chat
Help Users
    K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2: Damn spam callers keep ruining my hentai games each time they're about to climax