What do you think was the best Anime this season?

[Rubedo]

You know what needs to be in the poll?
Nurarihyon no Mago. It's awesome. I want to change my vote to it.

No it doesn't, for two reasons.
1. Because it's not from this season.
2. Because it sucks. It's almost as bad as Inuyasha.

My bad. Thought it started this season. forgot it started in July

I started watching it late :3
If you say so. I like it.

It's bottom of the barrel shounen. Worse than even Inuyasha, Naruto or Bleach.
Though I can't really blame you, you probably just haven't seen anything exceptionally good to compare it with.

 

[Zeroneo]

You know what needs to be in the poll?
Nurarihyon no Mago. It's awesome. I want to change my vote to it.

No it doesn't, for two reasons.
1. Because it's not from this season.
2. Because it sucks. It's almost as bad as Inuyasha.

My bad. Thought it started this season. forgot it started in July

I started watching it late :3
If you say so. I like it.

It's bottom of the barrel shounen. Worse than even Inuyasha, Naruto or Bleach.
Though I can't really blame you, you probably just haven't seen anything exceptionally good to compare it with.

To be fair, the anime really doesn't make justice to the manga.

 

[mameks]

You know what needs to be in the poll?
Nurarihyon no Mago. It's awesome. I want to change my vote to it.

No it doesn't, for two reasons.
1. Because it's not from this season.
2. Because it sucks. It's almost as bad as Inuyasha.

My bad. Thought it started this season. forgot it started in July

I started watching it late :3
If you say so. I like it.

It's bottom of the barrel shounen. Worse than even Inuyasha, Naruto or Bleach.
Though I can't really blame you, you probably just haven't seen anything exceptionally good to compare it with.

And what makes you think that? I don't really watch battle shounen, in fact extremely little, but I have watched quite a lot of anime, including some very good ones. Although you would probably say that they are utter shite.

 

[Rubedo]

You know what needs to be in the poll?
Nurarihyon no Mago. It's awesome. I want to change my vote to it.

No it doesn't, for two reasons.
1. Because it's not from this season.
2. Because it sucks. It's almost as bad as Inuyasha.

My bad. Thought it started this season. forgot it started in July

I started watching it late :3
If you say so. I like it.

It's bottom of the barrel shounen. Worse than even Inuyasha, Naruto or Bleach.
Though I can't really blame you, you probably just haven't seen anything exceptionally good to compare it with.

And what makes you think that? I don't really watch battle shounen, in fact extremely little, but I have watched quite a lot of anime, including some very good ones. Although you would probably say that they are utter shite.

Because it's a yokai story and yokai stories by nature are terrible. Plus it's been getting terrible ratings in Jump and if a magazine full of people who enjoy Naruto, Bleach and Reborn hate it, then it MUST suck.
I like lots of Anime, but I have rather high standards, as you can see here: http://myanimelist.net/animelist/FFandMMfa...s=7&order=0

 

[Aogu]

Because it's a yokai story and yokai stories by nature are terrible. Plus it's been getting terrible ratings in Jump and if a magazine full of people who enjoy Naruto, Bleach and Reborn hate it, then it MUST suck.
I like lots of Anime, but I have rather high standards, as you can see here: http://myanimelist.net/animelist/FFandMMfa...s=7&order=0

I think he is allowed to have an opinion?
And yeah it does get shit ratings in Jump and as you point out Jump is read by people who love Naruto etc. but then you failed in your conclusion... since Naruto etc are utter bollocks maybe the fact that the Jump readers don't like it is proof that it is: 1) Different 2) Not shit 3) Not just another naruto+beach etc.

Besides you claim all yokai are shit. Clearly you a wrong. Bakemonogatari?

As it happens I agree with most of your ratings on the anime you've watched, but I have to wonder about your so called "high standards" when I see: Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt rated 7/10 (Now you and shlong can get together and troll me

) and gunbuster 2 ranked 10/10 !?!?

 

[mameks]

Sure, a lot of yokai stories do suck balls, but honestly, I like NnM. You could also say the opposite; if the people that enjoy Naruto, Bleach and Reborn suck, then it's actually quite good? Or at least isn't shit.
As for high standards?
http://myanimelist.net/shared.php?u1=FFand...n&u2=shlong
EDIT: Damn shitty internet ninja'd me

 

[Rubedo]

Because it's a yokai story and yokai stories by nature are terrible. Plus it's been getting terrible ratings in Jump and if a magazine full of people who enjoy Naruto, Bleach and Reborn hate it, then it MUST suck.
I like lots of Anime, but I have rather high standards, as you can see here: http://myanimelist.net/animelist/FFandMMfa...s=7&order=0

I think he is allowed to have an opinion?
And yeah it does get shit ratings in Jump and as you point out Jump is read by people who love Naruto etc. but then you failed in your conclusion... since Naruto etc are utter bollocks maybe the fact that the Jump readers don't like it is proof that it is: 1) Different 2) Not shit 3) Not just another naruto+beach etc.

Besides you claim all yokai are shit. Clearly you a wrong. Bakemonogatari?

As it happens I agree with most of your ratings on the anime you've watched, but I have to wonder about your so called "high standards" when I see: Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt rated 7/10 (Now you and shlong can get together and troll me

) and gunbuster 2 ranked 10/10 !?!?


Bakemonogatari is not a yokai story.
7 isn't a particularly high rating coming from me, and of course Diebuster is a 10, why wouldn't it be?

QUOTE(shlong @ Dec 9 2010, 04:49 PM)

Sure, a lot of yokai stories do suck balls, but honestly, I like NnM. You could also say the opposite; if the people that enjoy Naruto, Bleach and Reborn suck, then it's actually quite good? Or at least isn't shit.
As for high standards?
http://myanimelist.net/shared.php?u1=FFand...n&u2=shlong
EDIT: Damn shitty internet ninja'd me

Your taste is pretty questionable.

 

[luke_c]

Quite clearly Toaru Majutsu no Index II. It has biri biri, what other explanation is needed?

 

[Rubedo]

Quite clearly Toaru Majutsu no Index II. It has biri biri, what other explanation is needed?

More importantly, it has Kuroko-desuno.

 

[Aogu]

Your taste is pretty questionable.

Then by extension so is yours? There's very little diffrence in your scores. By spearmans rank.. you have no significant correlation.

Too clarify: I actually did it the wrong way round and did a difference analysis not correlation.. so what the result is that there is no significant difference.

 

[8BitWalugi]

Digimon Xros Wars?

 

[dinofan01]

Dragon Ball Z. Am I doin it rite?

 

[Rubedo]

Your taste is pretty questionable.

Then by extension so is yours? There's very little diffrence in your scores. By spearmans rank.. you have no significant correlation.

Too clarify: I actually did it the wrong way round and did a difference analysis not correlation.. so what the result is that there is no significant difference.


Not really. While some of our ratings are the same, there are some where he has very good shows rated low, and some where he has very bad shows rated high.

Digimon Xros Wars?

Not from this season >_>

QUOTE(dinofan01 @ Dec 9 2010, 06:18 PM)

Dragon Ball Z. Am I doin it rite?

ololol

 

[Aogu]

Your taste is pretty questionable.

Then by extension so is yours? There's very little diffrence in your scores. By spearmans rank.. you have no significant correlation.

Too clarify: I actually did it the wrong way round and did a difference analysis not correlation.. so what the result is that there is no significant difference.

Not really. While some of our ratings are the same, there are some where he has very good shows rated low, and some where he has very bad shows rated high.

There are 2 shows where your opinion differs by more than 3/10. Statistically your ratings would be regarded as effectively identical...

 

[CamulaHikari]

It was really hard to choose, but eventually picked the one I rated the highest... *drum roll*

Bakuman~

 

[Frog]

Quite clearly Toaru Majutsu no Index II. It has biri biri, what other explanation is needed?

This.

 

[X D D X]

Bakuman easily.

 

[Rubedo]

Your taste is pretty questionable.

Then by extension so is yours? There's very little diffrence in your scores. By spearmans rank.. you have no significant correlation.

Too clarify: I actually did it the wrong way round and did a difference analysis not correlation.. so what the result is that there is no significant difference.

Not really. While some of our ratings are the same, there are some where he has very good shows rated low, and some where he has very bad shows rated high.

There are 2 shows where your opinion differs by more than 3/10. Statistically your ratings would be regarded as effectively identical...

Not really

 

[tenshinoneko]

out of all that long list all i know is pokemon xD

 

[Rubedo]

out of all that long list all i know is pokemon xD

...Perhaps you should watch more Anime then.