Review cover Kirby's Return to Dream Land Deluxe (Nintendo Switch)
Official GBAtemp Review

Product Information:

  • Release Date (NA): February 24, 2023
  • Release Date (EU): February 24, 2023
  • Release Date (JP): February 24, 2023
  • Publisher: Nintendo
  • Developer: HAL Laboratory
  • Genres: Kirby

Game Features:

Single player
Local Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer
Co-operative
We return to Dream Land once more with Kirby and friends to help a small wizard in need.

attachFull355788

Kirby games have always held a special place in my heart. They’re not known for their challenge so much as their charm and polish. To me, they’re comfort games. Joining the series back with Mouse Attack (or the better US title Squeak Squad) on the DS, I’ve seen Kirby through most of his modern adventures, and I’m yet to come out disappointed. Having missed the original Wii release of Return to Dream Land though, I’m excited to jump in now.

attachFull356070

If you’ve managed to avoid my favourite pink blob all this time, let me fill you in on the basics. Kirby is a happy and somewhat carefree resident of Dream Land. If they had their way, they’d probably spend his adventuring days sat under a tree indulging in sweet treats; it never quite works out that way though. For one reason or another, Kirby’s peaceful afternoons are thrown into chaos, and they must set out on journey after journey to live the life they so desire. The stories behind an average Kirby game is never particularly complex, but they are endearing in just how far Kirby’s willing to go in search of this peace, or to make their friends happy. Often caught up in the grandeur and sense of adventure, it’s easy to forget how simple the motivations often are. Mouse Attack as a keen example starts by Kirby’s strawberry shortcake being stolen, and ends in a fight with a possessed mouse and an evil God or something. Kirby just wanted the shortcake, and I love that.

Return to Dream Land starts out in a similar way to most Kirby games. You see a peaceful and green world with a few familiar faces lounging around or running with food. All is well, at least until it isn’t. Kirby’s push in this case is a giant spaceship appearing in the sky, and falling apart as it crashes down. Going to investigate, we meet a now-stranded Magolor in the ruins of his ship. Seeing how sad he looks, Kirby’s naturally right there to offer support and gather the parts Magolor needs to get back into the sky. With that, we’re on our way.

Review imageReview imageReview imageReview image

Coming to this game after recently playing Star Allies, it is a change to see a more traditional level selection screen. Taking me back to some of the oldest titles in the series, worlds are laid out as a 2D map not too different from an actual level. On these maps, you can see a bunch of closed doors where each represents a level, and each world ending in a boss battle. It’s a simple formula that works well, giving you a decent idea of what to expect and how long each world is likely to be. Once you’ve unlocked a level, you can also see your stats in terms of collectables both available and found. It’s good to have this knowledge prior to entering since you don’t always keep to the three collectable per level rule you might have become accustom to in games like the New Super Mario Bros series.

The levels themselves are unquestionably and ashamedly Kirby levels. It might sound like a silly thing to point out, but if you’ve played one Kirby game before, you’ll know exactly what you’re getting here. Not necessarily complex and rarely overly punishing, they’re a relaxed stroll where you’re encouraged to explore and engage with the level using the tools on offer. It’s common for the game to put something you want just out of reach as you run through a level. Close enough that it’ll catch your eye, but far enough away where you have to think about how to get it. It’s a good balance that doesn’t really strain you to play; it fits in with my general view of the Kirby series as comfort games to unwind to.

attachFull356069

Unique to Return to Dream Land are the super abilities. As Magolor’s ship crashed down, strange and shadowy objects fell with it. While it isn’t immediately obvious what these are or do, you’re soon introduced to them in the form of a particularly large and glowing enemy. As a great player of Kirby games, the natural instinct is to ingest such an enemy, and you’re rewarded well for such an instinct. Comparable to the Mega Mushroom of New Super Mario Bros, you gain a very strong version of the enemy’s power up with the caveat that you only have it for a brief period of time. The first of these, and the one you’ll have likely seen in some form of promotional material, is the Ultra Sword. When you attack with the Ultra Sword, you’ll both clear enemies off the screen, breaking the fourth wall a tad and smashing them into your display, and clear otherwise-unbreakable objects from the map. By getting to the end of the section with the power up, you’re able to enter another dimension that starts with you being chased by a really intimidating wall of something, and ending in a boss battle for some of those sweet sweet collectables. These sections are entirely optional, but to me they were some of the most enjoyable parts of the game.

While I do consider Kirby games to be relaxing rides, it’s certainly not to say there’s no kind of difficulty scaling as you progress through the story. Though not something I noticed so much from level to level, it is noticeable as you move from world to world, especially at the start of the adventure. Cookie Country serves as your typical green training wheel world that, in typical Kirby fashion, ends in a fight with everybody’s favourite tree. Moving out of there though and onto Raisin Ruins and beyond, I noticed myself taking more random hits and even dying a few times. It was never particularly frustrating, and I think a lot of my deaths came from being impatient more than the difficulty spiking out of nowhere.

attachFull356073

If you do find the game too difficult though, you do have a few options. The first is probably the obvious one: just skip the collectable. More often than not, the difficult areas of a Kirby game are the ones that are rewarding you for beating them, usually ending with an energy sphere or two. I managed to collect everything on my adventure, but if I were committed to collecting and found myself entirely against a brick wall, there was also another option. In Return to Dream Land Deluxe, you can call upon Magolor to assist you. He’ll throw you potions every so often, and also pick you up if you happened to fall down a hole and into the void. I’m never against optional helper features like this, especially in such an accessible game as Kirby. If you wanted to introduce a younger family member to the franchise or even gaming as a whole, something like could genuinely have a meaningful impact on their experience. I think that’s great.

On the other end of the spectrum though if you breezed through the main game, you might be happy to know there is an Extra Mode that takes the entirety of the base story and amps it up. Here, you’ll play with limited health against tweaked enemies and bosses. It is much the same game, don’t get me wrong, but only having 60% of your maximum health available was terrifying to me when I squeaked through a few of the later stages by a hit or two.

Review imageReview imageReview imageReview imageReview image

Though it might sound like a picky critique, I do think it’s a shame that no real malicious motivations are communicated throughout the game. To some extent, you’d ask why would there be? And that’s a reasonable question. But to ask something similar back, exactly why are the world bosses fighting you over these pieces of Magolor’s ship? Surely it’s just junk to them? There’s one exception to this that’s a brilliant fight, but the others feel like they could’ve been in any Kirby game. Compare this to a game like Planet Robobot where each boss fits the larger theme and serves a larger purpose, it all just feels a bit disjointed. It still makes for a fine Kirby game, but the series has shown it can be better than this.

Magolor Epilogue is a mode new to the Deluxe edition of Return to Dream Land. Set after the main story, it sees you control a now-powerless Magolor fight against enemies to collect magic points and restore his power. After each stage you return to the Ethereal Alter to allocate your magic points before heading out again. The core gameplay shares much of the Kirby charm and simplicity, but at least at the start puts a much heavier emphasis on traditional platforming with Magolor unable to fly. You’re also rewarded for building up combos of attacks with some decent magic point bonuses, this working towards an end of stage medal that ranges from bronze to platinum. I found from normal play a gold rank was easy enough to get. Platinum tended to take a bit more thinking to ensure I could both string together enough combos and not be hit out of them from being careless.

attachFull356068

This epilogue is a really cool addition, and really rounds out your traditional game modes nicely, but there’s obviously one more major mode you’ll probably expect if you’re a series veteran: the arena. Much like Magolor Epilogue, this is unlocked after beating the main story, but unlike the epilogue, you know exactly what you’re getting here. After picking your favourite power up, you’re thrown into a 13 round timed brawl against each of the game’s bosses. As always it’s a great challenge and a greater challenge if you’re trying to best your previous high score. With me being the type of player to play carelessly in search of a quick win, this is one of the harder parts of the game for me, and one I come back to when I want to re-experience some of the best parts of the game.

Outside of your primary game modes, Kirby’s Return to Dreamland Deluxe features a pretty lengthy assortment of subgames to enjoy, and they’re split between two areas of the game. The first of these is Merry Magoland, a charming theme park area run by Magolor. Here, you get ten games that are available to play pretty much out of the gate, each with a small assortment of missions to complete across three difficulty settings.  There’s a fun gameplay loop to be found. You’ll play games and receive stamps. Getting enough stamps will reward you with items to help you on your main adventure, but also cosmetic masks to wear. Some missions will require you to play the games wearing these masks, bringing you back, getting more stamps, and so on. The majority of these games are fairly simple and you’ll be getting through them within a minute or so of play, but they are fun and they’ll feel familiar for fans of the series. I enjoy the cosmetic masks a lot too since they carry over to the main adventure to customise Kirby just a little, and the missions are fun for guiding you towards an objective as you play instead of them just being standalone games. It’s kind of like how I prefer Harvest Moon DS to Friends of Mineral Town for how collecting Sprites gives much of the other game a guiding purpose.

Review imageReview imageReview imageReview imageReview imageReview image

The other way you’ll be interacting with subgames is as a reward for gathering this game’s collectables: energy spheres. At the centre of the world map, you can visit Magolor’s ship for an update of what’s still missing, but also to see what you’ve unlocked along the way. For your troubles, you’ll get an assortment of bonus challenge levels focused on a particular power, rooms that’ll let you just gain a power you’re after, and subgames. What’s a little odd here is that these are the same subgames you’ll find in Merry Magoland, but here they’re locked behind up to 115 energy spheres. What’s more, playing the unlockable versions doesn’t actually count towards the missions you can find in Magoland. If I had to guess, this was the original way you’d be able to play them, and Magoland is a Deluxe addition. Even so, it’s weird they’d leave these in as a reward when you start with them. It’s just a bit odd. I like Merry Magoland’s aesthetic and inclusion, but I do wish they reworked the content that was already present to not diminish the sense of reward for collecting the spheres. I don’t think I’d have minded Magoland having the games be locked.

attachFull356062

Can I recommend the Deluxe version of Kirby’s Return to Dream Land? Of course I can. This is a great Kirby game on a more versatile platform, with the added bonus of new and meaningful content. If you’re a fan of Kirby games or just want something fun to play with a few people on the sofa, you’ll have a great time ahead of you.

Verdict

What We Liked ...
  • A great and by the books Kirby outing
  • Nice assortment of subgames to enjoy
  • New mode added for Deluxe edition
  • Genuinely challenging hard mode available upon completion of main story
What We Didn't Like ...
  • Some unlockable content is available elsewhere now and doesn't really feel like a reward
  • Bosses don't seem to have any reason to be guarding the things you're fighting them for
9
Gameplay
This is Kirby, and it plays like Kirby. Our favourite pink blob still moves and acts like our favourite pink blob, and this really just makes for a refined and established platforming experience.
8
Presentation
The Deluxe port brings back some familiar Kirby graphics and just bumps the resolution up. It looked great on the Wii, and it looks better on the Switch.
8
Lasting Appeal
Return to Dream Land Deluxe has a great bounty of content that's easy to replay thanks to the huge variety of costumes and by extension, ways to play available. It's a game I'll definitely be returning to in future.
8.4
out of 10

Overall

Kirby's Return to Dream Land Deluxe is a great port of a great Kirby game. Keeping the magic of the original alive with a fresh coat of paint and meaningful new content, it's a game I can recommend to any lover of Kirby, platforming, or a good couch co-op experience.
First of all great review as always @Scarlet.

Is the Switch version worth it just for the extra content as I have played the original to death?
The new mode is great, but it really depends on whether you feel you'd enjoy the main story again since you do need to clear it in order to unlock most of the new stuff. In your position, I'd come back to the main story with some fun arbitrary restriction like no power ups to keep the experience fresh, and then enjoy the new content at face value.

You could also just look at it from the perspective of it being a game you already know you enjoy, and having a more convenient and slightly nicer looking way to play it.
 
I think an 8.4 is way too high.
Recently (recently as in 1 week ago) finished this game's original release. Had high hopes as it was my first time playing it too.

Music is boring and repetitive.
Power ups are not as cool as they were before.
Levels are easy to complete. Even the hidden gears are not hard to find.
Rarely died, so stacked up lives in huge amounts.
Bosses felt weak. It's not like before were you kind of had "weaknesses" to certain power ups.
The "MIX" power up mechanic felt odd. Instead of getting the "MIX" feature with two of the same or different enemies, you get them with two different or three of the same. Worst part is, tge game has 3 or more enemies at one scene very scarcely. So the "MIX" feature went totally unused for me except two times in the Ice world (whatever is called).

Ultra power ups are the worst gimmick I've ever seen in a Kirby game. I thought Planet Robobot was bad, but it seems that Kirby began to loose it's charm with Return to Dreamland onwards.
Ultra power ups are just used to open a new path, and then, puff! Gone.
Totally useless, and totally worthless for a gimmick fearured in the BoxArt of the game.

I see people often saying: "Kirby's 20th Anniversary was amazing"
Well, of course, old games, despite repeating the same formula, had a bigger challenge than newer games.

In my opinion, the last Kirby game that was good, was the old Mouse Attack (Squeak Squad never clicked as an official name).

Either way, Kirby is, seemingly, a personal experience, and Kirby just isn't Kirby anymore for me.

Heck, even the copy ability is more amusing in Smash than official Kirby games.
 
I think an 8.4 is way too high.
Recently (recently as in 1 week ago) finished this game's original release. Had high hopes as it was my first time playing it too.

Music is boring and repetitive.
Power ups are not as cool as they were before.
Levels are easy to complete. Even the hidden gears are not hard to find.
Rarely died, so stacked up lives in huge amounts.
Bosses felt weak. It's not like before were you kind of had "weaknesses" to certain power ups.
The "MIX" power up mechanic felt odd. Instead of getting the "MIX" feature with two of the same or different enemies, you get them with two different or three of the same. Worst part is, tge game has 3 or more enemies at one scene very scarcely. So the "MIX" feature went totally unused for me except two times in the Ice world (whatever is called).

Ultra power ups are the worst gimmick I've ever seen in a Kirby game. I thought Planet Robobot was bad, but it seems that Kirby began to loose it's charm with Return to Dreamland onwards.
Ultra power ups are just used to open a new path, and then, puff! Gone.
Totally useless, and totally worthless for a gimmick fearured in the BoxArt of the game.

I see people often saying: "Kirby's 20th Anniversary was amazing"
Well, of course, old games, despite repeating the same formula, had a bigger challenge than newer games.

In my opinion, the last Kirby game that was good, was the old Mouse Attack (Squeak Squad never clicked as an official name).

Either way, Kirby is, seemingly, a personal experience, and Kirby just isn't Kirby anymore for me.

Heck, even the copy ability is more amusing in Smash than official Kirby games.
I think saying that Kirby is a personal experience is a pretty good way to phrase it. I will say that I've never been too fond of picking scores for games, so take my scores with a pinch of salt. They're just numbers picked out of the air that feel right-ish.

To kinda show the different tastes here, Planet Robobot ended up being my favourite Kirby game, dethroning Mouse Attack when I played it. I went into it quite cynically at the time too, but I was entirely won over by how charming the game was and how the theming was so central to the game instead of it just feeling like a skin slapped on top. But yeah, different opinions really. I could never hate somebody for loving Mouse Attack lol
 
Honesty is a shame no more Nintendo Wii games got ported to the Switch. I remember this game and I got a Wii but back then I completely ignored it.

Dunno if something extra justifies buying it for the Switch when we have a better Kirby game for the Switch already with Kirby and the Forgotten Land.

This game really feels that could have easily released much early. Having this release so late in the Switch life is a real shame because Switch games aren't cheap and budgets are tight and Forgotten Land is overall a better game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Acetonide
Does this have the things from the wii anniversary game? I remember they padded the anniversary by reusing the engine and having some speed run mode or something
 
I think an 8.4 is way too high.
Recently (recently as in 1 week ago) finished this game's original release. Had high hopes as it was my first time playing it too.

Music is boring and repetitive.
Power ups are not as cool as they were before.
Levels are easy to complete. Even the hidden gears are not hard to find.
Rarely died, so stacked up lives in huge amounts.
Bosses felt weak. It's not like before were you kind of had "weaknesses" to certain power ups.
The "MIX" power up mechanic felt odd. Instead of getting the "MIX" feature with two of the same or different enemies, you get them with two different or three of the same. Worst part is, tge game has 3 or more enemies at one scene very scarcely. So the "MIX" feature went totally unused for me except two times in the Ice world (whatever is called).

Ultra power ups are the worst gimmick I've ever seen in a Kirby game. I thought Planet Robobot was bad, but it seems that Kirby began to loose it's charm with Return to Dreamland onwards.
Ultra power ups are just used to open a new path, and then, puff! Gone.
Totally useless, and totally worthless for a gimmick fearured in the BoxArt of the game.

I see people often saying: "Kirby's 20th Anniversary was amazing"
Well, of course, old games, despite repeating the same formula, had a bigger challenge than newer games.

In my opinion, the last Kirby game that was good, was the old Mouse Attack (Squeak Squad never clicked as an official name).

Either way, Kirby is, seemingly, a personal experience, and Kirby just isn't Kirby anymore for me.

Heck, even the copy ability is more amusing in Smash than official Kirby games.
Kirby is a game for kids that's why is too easy
 
Kirby is a game for kids that's why is too easy
I think saying that Kirby is a personal experience is a pretty good way to phrase it. I will say that I've never been too fond of picking scores for games, so take my scores with a pinch of salt. They're just numbers picked out of the air that feel right-ish.

To kinda show the different tastes here, Planet Robobot ended up being my favourite Kirby game, dethroning Mouse Attack when I played it. I went into it quite cynically at the time too, but I was entirely won over by how charming the game was and how the theming was so central to the game instead of it just feeling like a skin slapped on top. But yeah, different opinions really. I could never hate somebody for loving Mouse Attack lol
Yeah, precisely kept thinking this.
Maybe I'm too old for these games now.
I mean, I've spent all my gaming years playing old games, so perhaps I'm being based.
I'm so old that I just saw Scarlet's pictures of Max and I keep confusing it with Mexican Maguito Sonric's... which is an 80s Candy mascot:
images
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scarlet
I haven't had the time to start this game yet, but right off the bat...why does everything have such thick outlines now? I've seen the original Wii game, and there weren't no outlines there, no sirree, so why add 'em?

Next, I also prefer Dedede's original design over his Forgotten Land one; I dunno, he just seems too Club Penguin-y now, with his eyes too close together and having practically no neck. Just, eurgh, why? It was fine in Forgotten Land because you didn't see too much of him (he was mainly a boss, for one, and even when he arrived in the town he just laid down in one place), but when he's a playable character and thus has more screen time, and replacing a superior model at that...yeah, no, it's unforgivably awful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CoolMe and krakenx
Honestly, I'd rather play Robobot again; that was my first Kirby game, and also seems to be one of the best (though I've never played Super Star/Ultra yet, so...).
Or play through Forgotten for a second time, really.
 
i played the Wii Version of this game with my cousin's back in the day. we kinda did not care for it after a few stages... still i would love to see a Kirby Co-op Online Game other then super kirby clash.... it would be cool but that's wishful thinking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scarlet
Dunno if something extra justifies buying it for the Switch when we have a better Kirby game for the Switch already with Kirby and the Forgotten Land.
You are comparing "New Super Mario Bros." with "Super Mario Galaxy" here. 2D and 3D are completely different experiences in my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Acetonide
You are comparing "New Super Mario Bros." with "Super Mario Galaxy" here. 2D and 3D are completely different experiences in my opinion.

I am talking about "Gaming on a budget".

Is this game 40 bucks or less? Because if it costs 60 better buy Forgotten Land.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Cris1997XX
Just beat the main-game, Epilogue and Arena. I think it's pretty solid! I'd likely rank it around the same mark you did...I am pretty biased as the OG Wii game was my SECOND Kirby game (started with Super Star Ultra btw). I think the part that standed out the most for me was the lore implications of the Epilogue.

The confirmation that the Kirby Clash games (those free to play ones to be exact.) are canon, but just in another universe that Magolor was able to travel to after destroying the master crown for good...Meaning that characters such as Galacta Knight/Aeon Hero HAVE canonically appeared, just in another dimension as a whole...I have a feeling a future game might finally see the masked pink menace show up in a future title in Kirby's universe.

Overall yeah, pretty good remake of a pretty good game. Not as good as Super Star Ultra as a remake but still enough to warrant a purchase imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scarlet
Review cover
Product Information:
  • Release Date (NA): February 24, 2023
  • Release Date (EU): February 24, 2023
  • Release Date (JP): February 24, 2023
  • Publisher: Nintendo
  • Developer: HAL Laboratory
  • Genres: Kirby
Game Features:
Single player
Local Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer
Co-operative

Reviews

  1. Augmented reality (AR) glasses have become popular gaming companions recently. TCL’s AR branch, RayNeo even has a dedicated bundle, featuring the RayNeo Air 2 and JoyDock, aimed at the Nintendo Switch. Is this the AR gaming upgrade you’ve been looking for?

  2. Outcast 2: A New Beginning is an Action-Adventure game available for PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S and PC.

  3. Collect clues in your subject's memories, fix distorted fragments inside them, and push the Golden Butterfly out!

  4. The CP13 cassette player is the first in FiiO’s Retro line of products. Does the audio specialist do a good job at bringing back analogue music players?

  5. An exclusively-barebones keyboard, we check out NuPhy’s latest release in the Gem80!

Site & Scene News

General chit-chat
Help Users
  • K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2:
    That you'll only see once
    +2
  • Veho @ Veho:
    Double dickhead chinballs is still better than double dickhead eyeballs.
    +1
  • Veho @ Veho:
    As in, the balls will grow in your eye sockets.
  • K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2:
    I paid 5 grand to get them moved to my chin
    +1
  • Veho @ Veho:
    This you?
  • K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2:
    My hair can't be that cool
    +1
  • Veho @ Veho:
    Ah, yes, portrait mode, surely the best way to film a row of people. If only there were some way to fit a wider shot, at the expense of height... if only...
    +1
  • K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2:
    4k portrait mode?
    +1
  • BigOnYa @ BigOnYa:
    Diddy - "I never touched her, that bitch is crazy." Video is released. Diddy - " Ok I did it, i am remorseful for my actions during my darkest times." Lol
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    @BigOnYa, Glad that the Diddler got caught once again.
    +1
  • K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2:
    Iran ran out of options
  • K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2:
    Thought I saw my ex on that new kingdom of the Apes poster
  • BigOnYa @ BigOnYa:
    I thought I saw a puttie snatch...
  • BigOnYa @ BigOnYa:
    I'm so pumped, NCAA football video game is back after a 10 year hiatus, coming to SeriesS/X, PS5 in July.
  • BigOnYa @ BigOnYa:
    Wish they would let us play the NCAA football 14 on newer xbox, its one of the only games I love and own on disc still, that is not back compatible, bs.
  • AdenTheThird @ AdenTheThird:
    @BigOnYa My dad recently bought a spare Series X off of me, got game pass, and saw Madden '24 on Game Pass, decided to try it out.

    ...He was a bit taken aback by the 60GB download size. Poor guy's still living in the 90s!
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    @AdenTheThird, Bro's still in the PS2 age.
  • K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2:
    Lol charging your dad's classic unless he's the type that doesn't like taking things like that
    K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2: Lol charging your dad's classic unless he's the type that doesn't like taking things like that