Official Review Xbox Series X|S

South of the Circle (Xbox Series X|S)
Official GBAtemp Review

Name: South of the Circle
Item: South of the Circle
Rating: 7
Author: Prans

Product Information:

Release Date (NA): August 3, 2022
Release Date (EU): August 3, 2022
Publisher: 11 bit studios
Developer: State of Play
Genres: Adventure
Also For: Computer, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One

Game Features:

Single player

Local Multiplayer

Online Multiplayer

Co-operative

Narrative driven title South of the Circle from indie devs State of Play will have you traverse Antarctica while looking back at past events that brought you to this frozen landscape, while stuck in conflicts revolving around politics, relationships and promises. Should you take a trip to the south of the circle?

attachFull320412

On the way to start a research expedition in Antarctica, the plane in which climate scientist Dr Peter Hamilton is travelling crashes on the frozen land prior to reaching their destination. The pilot being injured, it’s up to Peter to seek help at Deception Point, the nearest base. However, once he reaches his destination, Peter discovers that no one seems to be present, even if someone is supposed to be stationed there all year round. What further fuels the mystery is that the base’s occupants seemed to have left in a hurry…

What happened here and how this all weaves into Peter’s story unfolds as South of the Circle’s plot progresses, which drifts back and forth between past and present events that connect the dots.

attachFull320413

As a narrative-driven title, South of the Circle stands out with its presentation. The visuals, despite being minimalist, eloquently portray each scene thanks to the professional voice acting and accompanying soundtrack throughout. These add an artistic appeal as well as cinematic feel to the game as a whole.

In addition to the original aesthetics, the way Peter’s story is told also brings in some novelty. As our protagonist braves the Antarctic weather in search of help, the scene alters between the past and the present when similar topics or actions are being enacted in different time periods. For example, at the start of the game, Peter is guided to the Deception Point base by a blinking red light which leads him to recall a memory when he was on the train back in England where the train station also had a similar blinking red light. At another point, Peter is driving a vehicle across the snow in Antarctica and he experiences a flashback to when he was driving his car in Cambridge. This storytelling technique feels captivating and really enticed me to learn more about the plot.

Peter’s memories aren’t random ones either but rather recall events that led up to his Antarctic expedition. These recollections also help piece his story together, which is one in conflict between relationships, career and promises, entangled in the backdrop of a political turmoil during the Cold War era when the game is set. While the plot’s nuances aren’t often very subtle, the original storytelling technique helps overlook this aspect.

attachFull320417

Regarding the gameplay, South of the Circle amounts mostly to a “walking simulator” interspersed with mini games. These range from turning dials on the radio to communicate, to riding a vehicle in the frozen continent. Mixing up the gameplay is the inclusion of dialogue prompts which are based on emotions. This means that you aren’t choosing between set replies but rather on what you think your reply should indicate (confusion, honesty, assertiveness, and the like). While in most cases these choices don’t have much of an influence on the story, in certain cases it does and this impacts part of the storyline.

However, the dialogue prompts, while original, can often get confusing. You need to pay attention to the symbols and what they mean, and this requires some getting used to, especially when first picking up the game. I’ve had to check the help menu quite a bit at the start to ensure I’m making the appropriate choice. Eventually, I got the hang of it and managed just fine.

attachFull320421

Moreover, even if you choose to not select a response, the game will automatically choose one for you if your time runs out (indicated by fading dialogue symbols). As most choices don't seem to have much of an influence, the impact of consequence, hence a challenge, is lacking in South of the Circle. Some of the other choices you make eventually impact a larger decision but my plotline didn’t feel that convincing based on my decisions.

As for the mini games that add some diversity to the gameplay, they feel repetitive in the long run. This is because the balance of those actions tilts towards dial tuning, and there's only so many dials I'd like to fiddle with in a game.

attachFull320425

That said, South of the Circle isn’t that long of a game, clocking at around 3 hours or so. It doesn’t offer much of a challenge, neither in its gameplay nor in its choices (where you might expect the challenge to lie) but the title does offer an interesting story wrapped in an appealing, minimalist art style. If this sounds appealing, then it might be worth taking a trip to the south of the circle.

South of the Circle | Release Date Announcement

Verdict

What We Liked ...

Original storytelling technique
Minimalist aesthetics
Cinematic vibe

What We Didn't Like ...

Dialogue prompts can be confusing
Lack of challenge
Repetitive gameplay aspects

Gameplay

Being mostly a walking simulator, South of the Circle brings some welcome variety to its gameplay but even those actions feel repetitive and overused.

Presentation

South of the Circle stands out with the cinematic presentation, complete with a fully voice acted plot, original soundtrack and artistic visuals.

Lasting Appeal

Clocking at around 3 hours, South of the Circle’s plot and visuals remain original enough to entice a complete playthrough despite repetitive aspects of its gameplay.

out of 10

Overall

South of the Circle offers a cinematic, narrative-driven experience that stands out with its minimalist visuals and captivating storytelling technique.

Reactions: Mama Looigi, Ahmir, KiiWii and 2 others

Cyan
Aug 5, 2022

Thanks for the review.
I saw that game in the new releases, I wasn't sure to like it.

If it's that short, I might give it a try. I like very short games and stories. Though, I don't like (cold) war as background.
I also don't like games with unsure dialogues where you expect something and it's the contrary, maybe with symbols as reaction it helps choosing ?

Reactions: Prans

V Viri
Aug 6, 2022

I don't know what that art style is called, but I can't stand it. Makes me think of that Untitled Goose Game's art style.

Reactions: Phearoz

Phearoz
Aug 6, 2022

Viri said:
I don't know what that art style is called, but I can't stand it. Makes me think of that Untitled Goose Game's art style.

Hate to be a hater, when it comes to art, but I hate it.

Phearoz said:
Hate to be a hater, when it comes to art, but I hate it.

At least it's not as bad as that god awful "Corporate art style", you know the one I'm talking about.

Reviews

Hardware
RayNeo Air 2 AR glasses and JoyDock Gaming Bundle

Augmented reality (AR) glasses have become popular gaming companions recently. TCL’s AR branch, RayNeo even has a dedicated bundle, featuring the RayNeo Air 2 and JoyDock, aimed at the Nintendo Switch. Is this the AR gaming upgrade you’ve been looking for?
PlayStation 5
Outcast 2: A New Beginning

Outcast 2: A New Beginning is an Action-Adventure game available for PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S and PC.
PlayStation 5
Read Only Memories: Neurodriver

Collect clues in your subject's memories, fix distorted fragments inside them, and push the Golden Butterfly out!
Hardware
FiiO CP13

The CP13 cassette player is the first in FiiO’s Retro line of products. Does the audio specialist do a good job at bringing back analogue music players?
Hardware
NuPhy Gem80 Mechanical Keyboard

An exclusively-barebones keyboard, we check out NuPhy’s latest release in the Gem80!

More reviews

Product Information:

Game Features:

South of the Circle | Release Date Announcement

Verdict

Overall

RayNeo Air 2 AR glasses and JoyDock Gaming Bundle

Outcast 2: A New Beginning

Read Only Memories: Neurodriver

FiiO CP13

NuPhy Gem80 Mechanical Keyboard