Official Review Xbox Series X|S

Review cover The Forest Cathedral (Xbox Series X|S)
Official GBAtemp Review

Product Information:

  • Release Date (NA): March 14, 2023
  • Release Date (EU): March 14, 2023
  • Publisher: Whitethorn Games
  • Developer: Brian Wilson
  • Genres: Adventure, platforming
  • Also For: Computer

Game Features:

Single player
Local Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer
Co-operative
Indie title The Forest Cathedral combines 3D, first-person exploration, 2D platforming and real events to deliver an “environmental thriller”. Is it a thrilling experience?

attachFull359673

History with some drama

In the 1960s, scientist Rachel Carson published an environmental book titled Silent Spring. The latter documents the nefarious effects of synthetic pesticides, such as DDT, on the environment at large. Her research paved the way for environmental protection actions that perpetuate today.

The Forest Cathedral puts us in control of the very same Rachel Carson on a field research on an island where she quickly discovers something is off with the ecosystem and might be tied to the recent DDT use.

However, The Forest Cathedral’s plot spices things up by dramatising the event. There are scenes of acute poisoning, close calls with wildlife and a menacing mad scientist. It’s an original way to translate the message of Silent Spring and the game deserves some recognition in this regard.

attachFull359674

Review imageReview imageReview image

A retro platforming game disguised in a modern title

It’s not just the plot that The Forest Cathedral mixes up but also the gameplay. The game initially starts off as a first-person exploration title with Rachel equipped with a notebook which serves as an objective guide, and scanner that can help her navigate in low visibility situations. She can also interact with a radio to communicate as well as solve puzzles. 

attachFull359678

Review imageReview imageReview imageReview image

So far, The Forest Cathedral isn’t far from a “walking simulator” but then you get introduced to a new gameplay aspect of the game when Rachel interacts with some terminals. These play out in a 2D, retro monochromatic platforming game where you’ll get to jump, dash and attack in order to reach your goal. Completing the latter will subsequently trigger an action which allows you to progress further into the story; even if the way this unfolds does not always feel natural.

It’s an interesting “games within games” concept which endows The Forest Cathedral with some originality. The platforming levels are what adds the most challenge to the game. The challenge is quite real, reminiscent of yesteryear games and can occasionally be frustrating, especially with the delay in executing attacks.

attachFull359684

Review image Review image

Not far from a forest fire

Unfortunately, this is not the only frustrating aspect of The Forest Cathedral. Despite an original reimagined plot based on actual events and interesting gameplay mechanics, the overall execution feels unpolished.

Sometimes the animations can feel off, the plot jumps across story beats and I’ve even experienced the voice over being drowned by the soundtrack.

Speaking of voice over, while the voice acting attempts to flesh out the characters, it is not devoid of its own issues. There are several cringe-worthy lines where Rachel talks to every piece of equipment and calls them Mr This and Mr That. Some performances can also be unconvincing, when Rachel expresses disbelief or attempted enthusiasm.

The ending is also quite abrupt, and culminates with an info dump which could instead have been slowly eased into the main story. 

attachFull359687

Review imageReview imageReview image

Thankfully, you don’t have to bear with the issues for too long as The Forest Cathedral is a short that you can finish in one sitting, should you decide to pick it up. It presents interesting experimental concepts which overall suffer from execution issues that hinders the title from being gripping.

The Forest Cathedral - Launch Trailer

Verdict

What We Liked ...
  • Original means of translating message from real book and facts
  • Experimental “game within game” aspect
What We Didn't Like ...
  • Overall unpolished execution
  • Recurring unconvincing voice acting and cringe-worthy lines
  • Unbalanced story progression
6
Gameplay
Mixing 3D, first person exploration and 2D platforming is the highlight of the game, even if the latter can occasionally get frustrating.
5
Presentation
The Forest Cathedral deserves recognition for the original way it translates the message from its inspiration but the unconvincing voice acting and unpolished execution aspect stick out like a sore thumb.
5
Lasting Appeal
The experimental aspect of the game is interesting but the execution and pacing issues mar the short-lived experience.
5.5
out of 10

Overall

Despite its original experimental premise, The Forest Cathedral suffers from an unpolished execution.
P
Sweet lord, could they have done a worse job on the character models? They clearly took a male character model and stuck some makeup on it. They didn't even put any effort into trying to make the character model look remotely feminine, let alone like the actual Rachel Carson. I like the idea of the game, it is quite unique and interesting, especially since it teaches people about an important event in recent science history, but the execution leaves terribly much to be desired.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maximumbeans
Maximumbeans
Paralel said:
Sweet lord, could they have done a worse job on the character models? They clearly took a male character model and stuck some makeup on it. They didn't even put any effort into trying to make the character model look remotely feminine, let alone like the actual Rachel Carson.
Click to expand...
Oh what the fuck, I didn't realise. I just read it as Mr Carson because I saw how clearly masculine the model was and my brain must have filled it in :rofl: that's dire
 
  • Like
Reactions: Paralel
Review cover
Product Information:
  • Release Date (NA): March 14, 2023
  • Release Date (EU): March 14, 2023
  • Publisher: Whitethorn Games
  • Developer: Brian Wilson
  • Genres: Adventure, platforming
  • Also For: Computer
Game Features:
Single player
Local Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer
Co-operative

Reviews

  1. Hardware

    RayNeo Air 2 AR glasses and JoyDock Gaming Bundle

    Augmented reality (AR) glasses have become popular gaming companions recently. TCL’s AR branch, RayNeo even has a dedicated bundle, featuring the RayNeo Air 2 and JoyDock, aimed at the Nintendo Switch. Is this the AR gaming upgrade you’ve been looking for?

  2. PlayStation 5

    Outcast 2: A New Beginning

    Outcast 2: A New Beginning is an Action-Adventure game available for PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S and PC.

  3. PlayStation 5

    Read Only Memories: Neurodriver

    Collect clues in your subject's memories, fix distorted fragments inside them, and push the Golden Butterfly out!

  4. Hardware

    FiiO CP13

    The CP13 cassette player is the first in FiiO’s Retro line of products. Does the audio specialist do a good job at bringing back analogue music players?

  5. Hardware

    NuPhy Gem80 Mechanical Keyboard

    An exclusively-barebones keyboard, we check out NuPhy’s latest release in the Gem80!

More reviews

Site & Scene News

Go to forum More news
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    that phat is mint too
  • BigOnYa @ BigOnYa:
    I would Not trust anything from gamestop, ive read people buying stuff new under warranty, then something happens and they return to get fixed under they warranty to only get a used 2nd hand unit back, that bs
     +1
  • Xdqwerty @ Xdqwerty:
    @realtimesave, i made some research and its a super slim
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    @realtimesave, I haven't modded a Xbox 360 before, looks easy to mod, but difficult to take apart lol. I've done OG Xboxes before.
  • Xdqwerty @ Xdqwerty:
    @BigOnYa, i heard dkoldies is worse
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    they aren't that hard to take apart. I can pop them apart with a jeweler's screwdriver any more
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    @Xdqwerty, DKOldies is a scam.
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    I've already seen a lot of videos about them, and people no longer care.
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    @Xdqwerty that's ok tho if you ever needed another model they are only like 60-80 dollars on offerup. pretty cheap
     +2
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    eBay sells Xbox 360s for £30.
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    I wonder if there's an hdmi adapter for the old model
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    cos that jtag works pretty damn good
  • Xdqwerty @ Xdqwerty:
    @SylverReZ, ik its a scam, thats why i mentioned it
     +1
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    even though it is a system prone to rrod which it doesn't have
     +1
  • BigOnYa @ BigOnYa:
    I would not recommend 360 phat models anymore, slims are better, and RGH3 possible, phats only rgh1 or jtag
     +1
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    ya but phat has ps2 chip in it :)
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    @BigOnYa, https://consolemods.org/wiki/Xbox_360:Buying_Guide
     +2
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    This is a great buying guide that I recommend.
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    my rgh systems glitch pretty damn fast
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    @BigOnYa, Except Winchester, which even to this day, is not moddable.
     +1
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    now I'm trying to figure out PS4 modding.
     +1
  • realtimesave @ realtimesave:
    looks easy
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    @realtimesave, It definitely did take a while for the PS4 to be fully hacked, much like the PS Vita.
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    Sony has announced that they will be using a non-x86 processor for their next-gen console.
  • BigOnYa @ BigOnYa:
    Amazon fire sticks switching to a custom linuxOs instead of Android, sucks for 3rd party some
    BigOnYa @ BigOnYa: Amazon fire sticks switching to a custom linuxOs instead of Android, sucks for 3rd party some