Bumping this, as I'm not sure if I'm having some problems. i've been reading up as much as possible on quality burning, using DVDInfoPro to check the quality, discs to use, etc. and wanted some feedback. I want to be able to burn a playable backup and an archival backup without worrying about deleting the iso to free up space.
Burning with a NEC ND-3540a that I believe I flashed up to a 3550a a while back, and on the newest stock 3550 RPC1 firmware (courtesy of Liggy). I just got into the TPhack/homebrew channel goodness the weekend before last, so i'm fairly new to the scene but i've been doing various console stuff for years (PS1, DC, PS2, GBA, DS, etc.) so I'm no spring chicken when it comes to the hacking and burning stuff. I do try to read and search as much as possible before asking FAQs.
I started burning with Sony DVD-R's and 2x, then bumped it up to Max after seeing people suggesting just trying different speeds and testing the quality. I did a burn of Castlevania: Judgment (2x) and while I don't get any crashes, I do hear the drive fighting to keep up with reading data, character changes on the select screen load slow, etc. I also did a burn of Boom Blox (16x) that seems rather perfect so far.
So, I got a hold of some Verbatim discs last night as the highest quality in DVDInfoPro I've seen was a Sony burn, probably at 2x, at 60%. Last night, I burned Lego Batman on Verbatims at 16x and 2x. The 16x reported a quality of 24%, the 2x rated at 0%. I haven't tested either in the wii yet, but just wondering if I'm doing something wrong somewhere, whether the NEC is just a bad drive for testing. I do have a LG GDR-8164b :B but DVDInfoPro won't do PI/PO testing with it, not sure whether it's an old firmware or just doesn't support it.
Any suggestions? Try Nero Drive Speed? :/ Sorry for the long post.
Update:
welp, i finally found an answer to my question after much searching:
http://club.cdfreaks.com/f86/pi-po-scannin...c-3550a-164489/
short answer is that the NEC-3550 is fairly unreliable for quality scanning, actually takes a regedit to get it to produce *somewhat* accurate ratings. feh. oh well... maybe i'll watch craigslist for a cheap pioneer drive. i guess the worst thing about this was: now having 7 backups of lego batman.